Parade Magazine Fudge

by Jillian
(Panama City, FL)

Making Homemade White Chocolate Fudge

Making Homemade White Chocolate Fudge

Tried the Parade Magazine Fudge. FAIL!! Can I save it?

So I found this recipe in this weekend's Parade Magazine (you know, that thing that gets stuck in the Sunday paper), and decided to make it, because it seemed easy enough, right?

Well, little did I know that it's not a *FULL* set of instructions!! Nothing about greasing the foil, nothing about how long to cook it or at what temperature (I kept it at low-medium, because otherwise it tried to volcano lava flow over on me), NOTHING!!

Long story short, it came out in this toffee colored, taffy consistency gooey mess. To top it all off, it's stuck to the aluminum foil!!

It took me over an hour to get first the marshmallow mix down to a "smooth" consistency, then another hour to get the chocolate chips to melt! Does anyone have any ideas what to do with this that can possibly save it?

It's $50 worth of stuff, and the only thing I'm going to have (or not have) for Christmas presents for everybody, because I'm unemployed and broke.

Thanks for any help. :)

Hi Jillian,

I know how disappointing it is to spend time and money making a yummy dessert and having it flop! There's good news when it comes to fudge. Often times fudge can be rescued and all is not lost.

I took a look at the recipe you linked to for the Parade Magazine Fudge and I can see why it would be difficult to produce successfully, especially if you are not a veteran fudge maker.

I like the easy fudge recipes. :) I'm definitely not one to spend two hours making fudge, when
it can be made in about 15 minutes in the microwave. Grin!

Anyway, back to your dilemma. If you can manage to peel all of the foil from your failed fudge, you may be able to save it by popping it back into the pan and reheating it and adding a few ingredients to the mix - evaporated milk and powdered sugar.

I'm wondering if you doubled or tripled the recipe the first time around. It sounds like you may have tried that since you said you spent so much money on the ingredients.

Fudge recipes usually do NOT double well. They need to be made one at a time. That may have been the real problem in why it took so long to get yours to come together.

If you've made a giant batch, try rescuing it a portion at a time. I can't give you exact measurements, but the idea is to loosen the fudge back up when melting with the milk and then use the powdered sugar to thicken/set it when stirring it. You may have to stir a lot to get that fudge consistency after you remove it from the heat.

It's hard for me to get an idea of the exact consistency and texture that you've ended up with. Usually when making a boiled candy fudge, you want the fudge mixture to get to the soft ball stage (around 235 degrees F.) If it doesn't get hot enough the fudge won't set and if you cook it too hot, you'll end up with a more chewy or too hard candy.

Hoping this helps and that you can salvage your fudge. Let us know if you do!

Merry Christmas,

Comments for Parade Magazine Fudge

Click here to add your own comments

Dec 21, 2012
Saving Your Parade Magazine Fudge NEW
by: Angie from

Hi Jillian,

Glad you were able to save some of it. Don't give up completely on the batch in the freezer. Bring it out and let it thaw and then try working in the powdered sugar. Even if you just knead it like bread to mix it through, you may end up with a good result. :)

As for the messy marshmallow pans, they're really not so bad. You just need to put some water in the pan and bring it to the simmer. The sugar will dissolve and you can dump it down the drain. If it's a bowl that's sticky from candy, just soak it in some hot water and voila!

All the best!

Dec 21, 2012
Kinda fixed ... a little NEW
by: Jillian

Yeah, I did double it, because I knew I needed to make a lot for everybody, and I remembered trying to get melted marshmallow out of bowls when we made Rice Krispies Treats as kids, and didn't want to have to fight that battle twice for two separate batches. Again, would have been nice for them to put that info in the "quick and easy" recipes page. :)

The pan that I put in the freezer I think is a total loss. The one that I left sitting on the counter I was actually able to mostly salvage. I put some powered sugar on the top (figuring it would work like flour on dough and make it a little less sticky), laid a piece of waxed paper on it, then flipped it over so the foil was on top. It came off in about 5 strips, but I managed to get it all off. I put some more powdered sugar on the bottom of it, and was able to cut it without much trouble, and zig-zagged 3 pieces in between wax paper strips and get them in a bag. They still look odd, but apparently they taste fine. Next time, I know better.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Your Favorite Fudge .

Search our Site:

Sign up for our FREE newsletter,
Charmingly Chocolate

E-mail Address

First Name


Don't worry -- your e-mail address is totally secure. I promise to use it only to send you Charmingly Chocolate.

Some of our delicious Site Sponsors

chocolate club

Chocolate Candy Mall Thank You